Carlisle Rental Realtor Dave
  • Residential Rentals
    • 5 Tree View, Carlisle, PA 17013 is a newer home in a great area of Carlisle with ample off street parking and plenty of closet space
    • 51 S Bedford St, Carlisle, PA 17015 is a new construction single family detached house for rent in Carlisle near the Army War College Barracks, geared towards military tenants
    • 262 Conway St, Carlisle, PA 17013 is a furnished rental home in the Mooreland School District
    • 616 W Louther St - Enjoy this duplex across from a park and deli, and less than a block from Dickinson College campus
    • 629 Hamilton St - 3bd 1.5ba with yard and off street parking
    • 1008 Blackstone Run, Carlisle, PA 17015 is a new build, end unit townhouse for rent near the Army War College Barracks available for year long leasing, geared towards military tenants
    • Nothing Suitable? Check out these FREE Search Tips or Join the Mailing List
  • Property Management
    • Property Management Services
    • Pricing for Carlisle Management
    • Over 15 Years of Experience
    • Property Management FAQ
    • Tips to find the right Property Manager >
      • 7 Tips to Find the Best Property Manager
      • Landlord's Guide to Hiring a Property Manager
      • 20 Qs to ask a Property Manager
      • Self Manage vs Hiring a Manager
      • 5 Property Manager Red Flags
  • Testimonials
  • More
    • The Application Process
    • Tenant Portal
    • Dave's Client Resources
    • Tenant Resources >
      • Renting 101: Free Tips for Tenants! >
        • Renting 101- General Rental Search Tips
        • Renting 101- My Local Recommendations Around Carlisle, PA
        • Renting 101- My Favorite Tenant Tips
        • Renting 101- Tips for First Time Renters
        • Renting 101- Tips for Military Renters
        • Renting 101- New Carlisle Tenant Resources
        • Renting 101- Carlisle Rental Search Tips
        • Renting 101- Attending Showings
        • Renting 101- Spring Tips for Tenants
    • Landlord Resources
    • Commercial For Lease >
      • Business Space for Lease
      • Office space for lease
      • Retail space for lease in Downtown Carlisle, PA
    • Buy
    • Sell
    • Join the Mailing List
    • Referral Program
    • Contact Dave
    • Contact Broker
Make your next tenancy a breeze with Carlisle's favorite Rental Realtor.
Residential Rentals
Commercial for Lease
Property Management

Carlisle Rental Agent Dave Fleming, PA Realtor #RS300174

Picture
I am a Realtor and Rental Manager focused exclusively on rentals in Carlisle, Pennsylvania. I have strong ties to the town as a real estate investor and resident since graduating Dickinson College in 2004. Renovating and managing historic buildings for our small family business piqued my interest in architecture and landlording. I've now been managing rentals full time for over two decades. I pride myself on developing personal, trusting relationships with tenants and landlords alike to ensure all parties enjoy a smooth and easy tenancy. I focus primarily on Carlisle, PA rentals to ensure I'm in the best position to get the right tenants as quickly as possible for all my clients while staying current with local laws, regulations, and market trends.
"I work with Dave Fleming who is a top notch and upstanding guy... Please send military renters his way as a trusted and reliable agent. I've had an exceptional experience with him. He's always been responsive, and he runs a reputable operation."
- Patrick Swan, Military Tenant
"Excellent Property Management!!! He’s has an excellent talent in balancing the needs of the renters and the owners.  He’s prompted on all requests of the rental. He will personally come out to assist when called to do so. He is a rare gem."
- Chenora Wilson, Tenant
Malieka, a landlord/owner says:
"Dave managed my residential rental for the last 5 years and is an absolutely fantastic property manager! He is communicative, proactive, responsive, detail-oriented, and treats both renters and owners respectfully and fairly... From the beginning of our collaboration, he provided high-quality tenant recruitment and retention. I can't recommend Dave highly enough!"

More Testimonials

Contact me directly to discuss your real estate needs.

Due to a high volume of solicitations, calls may not be answered. Please leave a voicemail, text, or email.

Picture
Rental Realtor Dave Fleming #RS300174
with
Distinctive Property Management, LLC #RB070109
Picture
Email Rental Realtor Dave Fleming
​Call or Text Dave at 717-559-2787

Call Broker at 717-860-0623
Why Rent from Realtor Dave?
​Tenants choose renting from Rental Realtor Dave Fleming because he is responsive, helpful, and provides a smooth rental experience. He has dozens of 5-star reviews from tenants and always takes pride in being a great resource for renters in and around Carlisle, PA. His experience is undeniable, and, in over 20 years of managing properties, not a single current or former tenant has left negative remarks about their experience with Dave. This is most impressive when see how frequent complaints are levied against other property management companies and rental Realtors in their reviews. Tenants feel comfortable leasing from Dave, confident they'll have a pleasant tenancy based on all those tenants who came before and shared their experiences. You can read testimonials from tenants on Facebook, Zillow, Google Maps, or by clicking here.

Landlords prefer Dave Fleming for leasing and property management because he's highly responsive and handles all aspects of the process.  He balances the needs of both renters and owners, ensuring smooth transactions and positive experiences.  Dave is known for his promptness in addressing requests and even oversees renovations to maximize rental potential.  His proactive, solution-oriented approach and professional manner make him a pleasure to work with.  He's dedicated to finding the right tenants and maintaining properties in excellent condition.  Landlords appreciate his commitment to maximizing their investment while providing quality housing and happy tenancies. Dave's focus on clear communication and efficient problem-solving sets him apart. He's a trusted partner for landlords seeking stress-free property management. Find out more about Dave's path to managing rentals in Carlisle and the surrounding areas or review what his clients have said about him on Zillow, Facebook, Google Maps, or by clicking here.
Why Rent in Carlisle, PA?
​Carlisle whispers a tale of small-town charm woven with threads of vibrant possibility.  Brick sidewalks, lined with centuries-old architecture, invite leisurely strolls past locally owned boutiques and the tantalizing aromas drifting from a diverse collection of restaurants – a culinary journey spanning global flavors.  The air hums with a quiet energy, a balance between the tranquility of the Cumberland Valley and the thrum of a community rich in history and culture.  Here, the pace slows, allowing appreciation for the simple pleasures: an afternoon browsing art galleries, catching the latest release at the local cinema, or discovering a unique treasure in one of the many shops.

Yet, Carlisle isn't just a haven of quietude. It’s a launching pad. The pulse of major metropolitan areas is within easy reach.  A quick drive or train ride connects you to the historical grandeur of Philadelphia, the vibrant harbor of Baltimore, the political heart of Washington D.C., the industrial legacy of Pittsburgh, and the electric energy of New York City.  This proximity offers a unique blend – the peace of a close-knit community coupled with the boundless opportunities of the East Coast's major cities.

Nature's embrace is also close at hand. The rolling hills surrounding Carlisle beckon with promises of adventure.  The legendary Appalachian Trail weaves its way through the landscape, offering challenging hikes and breathtaking vistas.  For a gentler exploration, the Cumberland Valley Rail Trail stretches invitingly for thirteen miles, perfect for a leisurely bike ride or a horseback adventure.

​Even a simple walk along local trails reveals the beauty of Pennsylvania's countryside. In Carlisle, life unfolds at your own pace, a harmonious blend of small-town comfort and big-city access, all wrapped in the beauty of the natural world.


I'm looking for a rental...
  • To live in (click here)
  • To do business in (click here)
Error: Embedded data could not be displayed.
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Residential Rentals
    • 5 Tree View, Carlisle, PA 17013 is a newer home in a great area of Carlisle with ample off street parking and plenty of closet space
    • 51 S Bedford St, Carlisle, PA 17015 is a new construction single family detached house for rent in Carlisle near the Army War College Barracks, geared towards military tenants
    • 262 Conway St, Carlisle, PA 17013 is a furnished rental home in the Mooreland School District
    • 616 W Louther St - Enjoy this duplex across from a park and deli, and less than a block from Dickinson College campus
    • 629 Hamilton St - 3bd 1.5ba with yard and off street parking
    • 1008 Blackstone Run, Carlisle, PA 17015 is a new build, end unit townhouse for rent near the Army War College Barracks available for year long leasing, geared towards military tenants
    • Nothing Suitable? Check out these FREE Search Tips or Join the Mailing List
  • Property Management
    • Property Management Services
    • Pricing for Carlisle Management
    • Over 15 Years of Experience
    • Property Management FAQ
    • Tips to find the right Property Manager >
      • 7 Tips to Find the Best Property Manager
      • Landlord's Guide to Hiring a Property Manager
      • 20 Qs to ask a Property Manager
      • Self Manage vs Hiring a Manager
      • 5 Property Manager Red Flags
  • Testimonials
  • More
    • The Application Process
    • Tenant Portal
    • Dave's Client Resources
    • Tenant Resources >
      • Renting 101: Free Tips for Tenants! >
        • Renting 101- General Rental Search Tips
        • Renting 101- My Local Recommendations Around Carlisle, PA
        • Renting 101- My Favorite Tenant Tips
        • Renting 101- Tips for First Time Renters
        • Renting 101- Tips for Military Renters
        • Renting 101- New Carlisle Tenant Resources
        • Renting 101- Carlisle Rental Search Tips
        • Renting 101- Attending Showings
        • Renting 101- Spring Tips for Tenants
    • Landlord Resources
    • Commercial For Lease >
      • Business Space for Lease
      • Office space for lease
      • Retail space for lease in Downtown Carlisle, PA
    • Buy
    • Sell
    • Join the Mailing List
    • Referral Program
    • Contact Dave
    • Contact Broker