See what my valued clients, colleagues, and tenants are saying about their experience with me.
"Dave was honestly the best landlord I've had in 40 years of living." - Matt, tenant
"Exceptional." - Patrick, military tenant
"Dave took over from another realtor company I was having trouble with before they went under. He was great, took care of everything and always responded within hours at the latest. Got along well with the tenants as well. I have recommended already and will do so again in the future." - Todd Bryant, owner / landlord
"Dave was hands down, the best realtor that I have ever dealt with in the rental industry. As a member of the military, I have spent the majority of my career in rental properties all over the world. The constant moving in and out of properties can wear on you. Dave made the entire process seamless from start to finish, check-in and check-out. I highly recommend this trustworthy and responsive realtor!" -Richard Martucci, tenant
Review your experience with me at
What do you think of your experience with Dave?
"I work with Dave Fleming who is a top notch and upstanding guy... Please send military renters his way as a trusted and reliable agent. I've had an exceptional experience with him. He's always been responsive, and he runs a reputable operation."
- Patrick Swan, military tenant See original review here.
"Excellent Property Management!!! He’s has an excellent talent in balancing the needs of the renters and the owners. He’s prompted on all requests of the rental. He will personally come out to assist when called to do so. He is a rare gem."
- Chenora Wilson, tenant see original review on Google
"Dave was honestly the best landlord I've had in 40 years of living."
- Matt Winslow, tenant
"Dave took over from another realtor company I was having trouble with before they went under. He was great, took care of everything and always responded within hours at the latest. Got along well with the tenants as well. I have recommended already and will do so again in the future."
- Todd Bryant, owner See original review here.
- Patrick Swan, military tenant See original review here.
"Excellent Property Management!!! He’s has an excellent talent in balancing the needs of the renters and the owners. He’s prompted on all requests of the rental. He will personally come out to assist when called to do so. He is a rare gem."
- Chenora Wilson, tenant see original review on Google
"Dave was honestly the best landlord I've had in 40 years of living."
- Matt Winslow, tenant
"Dave took over from another realtor company I was having trouble with before they went under. He was great, took care of everything and always responded within hours at the latest. Got along well with the tenants as well. I have recommended already and will do so again in the future."
- Todd Bryant, owner See original review here.
Property Management Landlord Testimonials
"Dave has done a great job managing my property in Carlisle. He is very responsive and even oversaw some renovation work between tenants to ensure the property could be rented at top market rate... If you need a full service Property Manager in the Carlisle area, check him out."
- Bob T, owner see original review on Google
"Dave has done a wonderful job of managing my rental for about 1.5 years. He is responsive, solution oriented, and a pleasue to work with."
- Malieka B, owner see original review here.
"Frequent communication and he works well with the tenants."
- Todd B, owner see original review on Google
- Bob T, owner see original review on Google
"Dave has done a wonderful job of managing my rental for about 1.5 years. He is responsive, solution oriented, and a pleasue to work with."
- Malieka B, owner see original review here.
"Frequent communication and he works well with the tenants."
- Todd B, owner see original review on Google
Tenants of Carlisle Rental Manager Dave
"No problem was too big or too small and all of them received his prompt attention. It was one of the smoothest move-in, stay, and move-out, I have had"
- Kara Shah see original review on Google
"Throughout the entire process of trying to find a rental property remotely, contract execution, and finally vacating the property, Dave was incredibly responsive, helpful and refreshingly personable to work with. In a year that was irrevocably impacted by Covid-19, Dave made any and all interactions pleasant and effective, and he took all necessary precautions to keep his clients safe. I highly recommend his services."
- Peg Grunewald see the original review on Zillow
"Working with Dave was a true pleasure. He was professional and very responsive to us as clients. His ability to balance the needs of the owners as well as the tenants was superb. As a military member I approve of him and his business."
-Chester Wilson, tenant see original review on Google
"I contacted Dave about an apartment listed on Craigslist and he responded within an hour, and was more than helpful in trying to accommodate our needs for an apartment. Although we didn't end up renting from this company, I was very impressed with their helpful and quick responses. We've dealt with many realtors and property managers that could care less about their property condition or tenant satisfaction. Allen & Fleming was a breath of fresh air! It's clear that this company and its employees, specifically Dave, are genuinely interested in their business and want everyone to have the best experience possible! Allen & Fleming will be my first place to go next time we're in the market for an apartment in Carlisle. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED."
-Erin Keiser, renter
"I am a previous tenent of Allen and Fleming partnerships and I wish I still rented off of them! I highly recommend them to anyone looking to rent in the Carlisle area. If I didn't move out of town I would still be living where I was. My apt was on N. Bedford Street which was in nice walking ditance to everything downtown. The apt was well kept and didn't have any major issues. If I did have any issues I would call Dave and he would be over asap to help me. He was always friendly and helpful if I needed anything. I miss renting off of them!!"
-Sarah Hower, renter see original review on google.com
- Kara Shah see original review on Google
"Throughout the entire process of trying to find a rental property remotely, contract execution, and finally vacating the property, Dave was incredibly responsive, helpful and refreshingly personable to work with. In a year that was irrevocably impacted by Covid-19, Dave made any and all interactions pleasant and effective, and he took all necessary precautions to keep his clients safe. I highly recommend his services."
- Peg Grunewald see the original review on Zillow
"Working with Dave was a true pleasure. He was professional and very responsive to us as clients. His ability to balance the needs of the owners as well as the tenants was superb. As a military member I approve of him and his business."
-Chester Wilson, tenant see original review on Google
"I contacted Dave about an apartment listed on Craigslist and he responded within an hour, and was more than helpful in trying to accommodate our needs for an apartment. Although we didn't end up renting from this company, I was very impressed with their helpful and quick responses. We've dealt with many realtors and property managers that could care less about their property condition or tenant satisfaction. Allen & Fleming was a breath of fresh air! It's clear that this company and its employees, specifically Dave, are genuinely interested in their business and want everyone to have the best experience possible! Allen & Fleming will be my first place to go next time we're in the market for an apartment in Carlisle. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED."
-Erin Keiser, renter
"I am a previous tenent of Allen and Fleming partnerships and I wish I still rented off of them! I highly recommend them to anyone looking to rent in the Carlisle area. If I didn't move out of town I would still be living where I was. My apt was on N. Bedford Street which was in nice walking ditance to everything downtown. The apt was well kept and didn't have any major issues. If I did have any issues I would call Dave and he would be over asap to help me. He was always friendly and helpful if I needed anything. I miss renting off of them!!"
-Sarah Hower, renter see original review on google.com
I always have owner and tenant references I'm happy to provide so you can hear first hand how their experience was with me as their landlord or manager. I encourage you to check at least a couple of any manager's references before signing a contract with them to be confident you'll get the service you expect.
Still not convinced? Here are some other offerings that set us apart from most other property management brokerages:
- The most 5-star reviews of any Central PA management company as of February, 2025.
- No hidden fees - Management is all inclusive. Some contracts may vary.
- Local - Dave is a Dickinson College graduate and a Carlisle, PA resident. See you around town!
- Transparent - Tenants and Landlords will actually work with Dave.
- Visible - Google Dave Fleming in Carlisle PA or Distinctive Property Management in Carlisle, PA.
- A long history of 5-star ratings from both landlords and tenants.
- Use your own contractor. Transparent vendor list and contractor pricing.
- Multiple estimates for no additional charge.
- Among the most extensive initial inspection and move-out photos are included. Some contracts may vary.
